Swiping right on real life

Let's be honest, modern dating has become digital overthinking at its finest. Your phone lights up with a dating app notification, and suddenly you're analysing response times and emoji choices like secret codes. Meanwhile, your potential match is having the exact same meltdown over your use of "haha" instead of "lol".

It's exhausting, artificial, and somehow, we've normalised this bizarre digital dance. Yet as more people tire of endless scrolling and the idea of "choice paralysis", there's a quiet return to something radical... meeting face to face and having actual conversations.

The situationship challenge

We've all heard of the dreaded "situationship", that relationship limbo where you're definitely more than friends, possibly sleeping together, but heaven forbid anyone use the word "commitment." It's rather like test-driving a car for months with no intention of ever buying it.

As Compatico's Relationship Expert, Tiare Tolks, explains, "People think they are craving romance but they're actually after connection." And she's right. We've somehow created a dating culture where we have unlimited access to potential partners but feel more disconnected than ever.

Companionship is the real luxury

Tiare notes, in her refreshingly candid way, 'In my experience a lot of people are more interested in companionship – someone to have fun with, share their Saturday mornings with and a little offloading along the way. It isn’t always about physical intimacy... you have a vibrator for that.”

There's something brilliantly liberating about this perspective. What's genuinely scarce in our lives are people who will listen to your work drama, remember your coffee order, and still want to see you when you're wearing your oldest, most comfortable jumper.

The first date façade

First dates can be bizarre social experiments. Two people, often dressed in clothes they rarely wear, sit across from each other, trying to be their most charming selves while simultaneously assessing if this stranger might enjoy meeting their family.

"When you go on that first date, tensions are often high, it's unnatural," Tiare explains. "The first date really should be treated lightly; you have to push past the first date to find out more about someone. It's a shame how frequently people write each other off after just the first date, Unfortunately, modern dating culture reflects a broader societal pressure for perfection.”

We recently heard a good news story about a Compatico couple Hannah (44) and Tom (47)* who discovered that sometimes the best love stories need a second chance to begin. Their first date was pleasant but 'the spark' wasn't there. They parted ways amicably, both thinking it was another 'nice but not quite right' encounter in the world of modern dating and decided there would be no second date. However, fate had different plans. A month or so later, they ran into each other socially while out with friends. This time, without the pressure of a formal date, the chemistry ignited! All the awkwardness was gone and in its place was fun and connection. Four months later, they are still together and going strong. A reminder to not write someone off just because the first date wasn't fireworks. Sometimes the best connections just need a little time to truly spark!

Tiare reminds us that magic usually happens with "repeated exposure". Judging someone after one date is judging a book by its cover, except the cover is wearing uncomfortable shoes and trying not to spill its drink!

Connection: it's what keeps us alive (literally)

"When we feel connected, we feel alive" Tiare explains. So perhaps the return to face-to-face dating isn't just nostalgic whimsy. "Sadly, there's a misnoma that this can be achieved by words on a screen, and it can’t, there is nothing like bodies in a room.” Maybe it's our collective recognition that endless swiping isn't filling our cups, that scrolling profiles at 1am isn't the path to meaningful connection and that there's wisdom in how previous generations approached building relationships.

Tiare wisdom

In a balance of wisdom and practicality, Tiare reminds us to “Be authentic” and "Be clear on what is important to you, know your values and stand firm in them. You don't necessarily need to share your values right off the bat but know when they are being infringed on.”It's like marinating chicken... timing matters. Revealing your authentic self is important, but dropping your complete five-year plan during appetisers might be overwhelming. Good relationships, like good cooking, require patience. Don't rule someone out straight away.”

As we find our way through the modern dating world of situationships and digital connections, perhaps the most revolutionary act is returning to basics: meeting in person, focusing on genuine compatibility and giving connections time to develop naturally. In a nutshell, hold things lightly and be up for an adventure. After all, what we're truly seeking are those meaningful connections that make life richer, and those take time to develop.
Perhaps it's time to start swiping right on real life.

*Names changed for privacy.

Ready to try a different approach in 2025? Our team would love to discuss how we can help you, just book a free complimentary 15-minute chat here.